A park ranger handing a violation notice to a couple in their car at a Yellowstone pull-out, a moose in the meadow behind
Cited in the park. The question is whether you can come back, and whether you need to.
Non-citizens · Yellowstone and Grand Teton

Cited in the park on a visa or ESTA. Can I come back?

Visitors on ESTA, tourist visas, H-1Bs and student visas drive through Yellowstone and Grand Teton every summer, and some fly home with a federal violation notice. The question they ask me first is whether it will keep them out of the United States. For most charges the answer is no. For one charge it can be yes, and for every charge the honest answer on the next form depends on how the case ends. Do not pay the notice until someone who understands both the criminal case and the immigration consequences has read it.

Start
Tell me your status and the charge; those two facts set the plan
Chat now
Call or text
Jackson, Wyoming · Mountain time
Text
Do not
Pay it, or explain it.
Paying closes the case with the regulation on the record; explaining to a ranger or prosecutor may be an admission of the facts.

Call or text me. Clients get my cell number from day one, and I answer. Got a violation notice? Here's what happens next.

Contact me now.

Three fields, thirty seconds. My office calls you back, usually the same business day.

Sending this doesn't create an attorney-client relationship, and I can't treat it as confidential until we've cleared conflicts, so keep it general. By sending, you agree we may reply by phone, email, or text.

In your language · 中文 · 한국어 · 日本語 · Español · Français · Deutsch · Italiano

Read it in your language. Talk it through in your language.

Every page of this National Parks chapter is written in Chinese, Korean, Japanese, Spanish, French, German and Italian. The consultation is a video call with attorney Aaron Herzberg, carried in your language by live translation software, at no additional charge.

Aaron Herzberg
Live translation · video consultation
A video consultation with attorney Aaron Herzberg, in your language.
Live translation software on the callBy video, from wherever you areNo additional charge for the translation

Three provisions that turn a ticket into a problem.

Controlled substances.

A non-citizen is inadmissible if convicted of, or if they admit committing, a violation of "any law or regulation of a State, the United States, or a foreign country relating to a controlled substance" (8 U.S.C. § 1182(a)(2)(A)(i)(II)). There is no exception for a small amount.

Moral turpitude.

Convictions for crimes involving moral turpitude carry their own consequences, softened by a petty-offense exception for a single offense whose maximum penalty is a year or less and whose actual sentence was six months or less (§ 1182(a)(2)(A)(ii)(II)). Most park regulations are not turpitudinous at all.

The definition of conviction.

Immigration law has its own definition: a formal judgment of guilt, or, where adjudication is withheld, a plea or an admission of sufficient facts together with some penalty or restraint (§ 1101(a)(48)). No immigration authority has yet said how it reads a paid park notice.

A passport on a car dashboard with the Teton Range through the windshield
The drive out of the park is where this question gets asked

Can I come back? Charge by charge.

Most visitors can come back. The charge decides how.

Two forms do the asking: the ESTA questions for Visa Waiver travellers, and the DS-160 for everyone who needs a visa in their passport. They ask different questions, and the truthful answer to each depends on what you were cited for and how the case ended.

What the forms actually ask
  • ESTA. "Have you ever been arrested or convicted for a crime that resulted in serious damage to property, or serious harm to another person or government authority?"
  • ESTA. "Have you ever violated any law related to possessing, using, or distributing illegal drugs?"
  • DS-160. "Have you ever been arrested or convicted for any offense or crime, even though subject of a pardon, amnesty, or other similar action?"
  • DS-160. "Have you ever violated, or engaged in a conspiracy to violate, any law relating to controlled substances?"
What the officer at the airport sees
  • An open federal case with a missed court date, and any warrant that followed it
  • An arrest with fingerprints, which is how a park DUI begins
  • A conviction entered by the court after a plea or a trial
  • Not a notice paid by mail to the Central Violations Bureau, which does not ordinarily appear as a case on the court's docket

Read the question as it is worded and answer it truthfully. A false answer on either form is a misrepresentation, and a misrepresentation to get into the United States is a permanent bar (8 U.S.C. § 1182(a)(6)(C)(i)). No park ticket is worth that.

Speeding, careless driving and other traffic notices. Not a crime of serious harm, not a drug law, and not an arrest: a notice handed to you at the roadside is not an arrest on the DS-160. What still matters is how the case ends. A Box A notice has a court date whether or not you are in the country, and a notice at thirty or more over cannot be paid at all; a dismissal or a forfeiture reads very differently from a conviction on a form that asks for the disposition.
Yes, once it is resolved. How it ends is the call.
Open container, approaching wildlife, off the boardwalk, other petty offenses. The same two answers, so long as you were not taken into custody. The thing to avoid is a conviction with probation and a park ban: probation is a federal court order to keep, and the green-card and naturalization forms ask about it by name. The resolution I aim for is a payment to the court and no conviction.
Yes. Settle it in a way that leaves no probation behind.
DUI, or refusing the breath test. A park DUI begins with an arrest, so the DS-160 answer is "yes" from now on, with an explanation. A single DUI with no crash and no injury is not a crime of moral turpitude and is generally not a "serious harm" answer on ESTA; if anyone was hurt, ask immigration counsel before you answer. Two consequences are real. A consular officer must send anyone with an alcohol-related arrest in the last five years to a panel physician before issuing a visa (9 FAM 302.2-7(B)(3)), and the State Department can cancel the visa already in your passport on the arrest alone (9 FAM 403.11-5(B)). Plan the next trip around a consular appointment, not around the case.
Usually yes. The arrest follows you; the visa may not.
Marijuana, or any other drug. This is the one charge that can close the door. ESTA and the DS-160 ask whether you have ever violated a drug law, not whether you were convicted, and a conviction or an admission makes you inadmissible with no exception for a small amount (§ 1182(a)(2)(A)(i)(II)); a visitor's waiver exists but is discretionary and slow. Paying the $400 notice is not an admission or an adjudication under the federal court's 2026 rule, but it leaves a controlled-substance regulation on your record and forecloses the dismissal that would let you answer the question cleanly. Do not pay it, and if you can, call before your flight home.
That depends on how the case ends. Do not pay it.
A notice you ignored. A missed Box A date brings a summons and then a warrant, and a federal warrant sits in the database Customs and Border Protection checks at every port of entry. A Visa Waiver traveller can be refused at the desk; a visa holder can be sent to secondary and turned around; anyone can be arrested on the warrant. It is fixable from abroad through counsel. It is not fixable at the airport.
Not until it is cleared. Never fly in with it open.

General information about the forms as they read today, not advice on your answer. The forms change, your facts matter, and an immigration lawyer should see the disposition before you apply. I handle the criminal side so the disposition is one worth showing.

What each kind of citation means for status.

Marijuana and other drugs

For a non-citizen, the aim of the case is a disposition that is not a controlled-substance conviction and does not involve an admission of the elements: dismissal, an amendment to a non-drug regulation, or a deferred agreement whose terms are drafted with the immigration definition in front of both lawyers. Whether that is achievable turns on the facts and the prosecutor, and it is pursued in every case. A citizen who pays a $400 marijuana notice has a Bureau record under a controlled-substance regulation; a visa holder who pays it has handed an officer a question that a dismissal would never have raised. The marijuana page.

DUI and refusal

A simple driving-under-the-influence conviction is generally not treated as a crime of moral turpitude, and a Class B misdemeanor is within the petty-offense exception in any event. The consequences are practical rather than statutory: a federal misdemeanor to disclose, a possible custodial sentence that interrupts employment, a one-year ban from driving on federal lands if the breath test was refused, and, for some, a Canadian border that treats impaired driving as serious criminality. Refusal of the breath test is a separate charge with its own record. The park DUI page.

Where it gets askedForms and moments
  • 01Nonimmigrant visa applications, which ask whether you have ever been arrested or convicted of any offense
  • 02Adjustment of status and consular immigrant-visa processing, where criminal history is reviewed with the file
  • 03Naturalization, which asks about citations, arrests, and convictions, and requires good moral character for the statutory period
  • 04Trusted-traveler and border programs on both sides of the Canadian line
  • 05Employer-sponsored petitions and renewals, where counsel asks the employee the same questions the forms will

The answer to each is easier when the court file says "dismissed" than when it says "collateral forfeited." The EB-1 and green-card page covers a pending I-485 or N-400 in detail.

Tell me your status and the charge. The call takes thirty minutes.
I handle the criminal side, in conversation with your immigration counsel, yours or one I can recommend.

Deportability, the visa in your passport, two lawyers.

The paid-notice question, deportability, DUI visa revocation, the other charges, two lawyers

The paid notice and the definition

Under the 2026 rule of the United States District Court for the District of Wyoming, the federal court for Yellowstone National Park and Grand Teton National Park, a paid collateral forfeiture is neither an admission nor an adjudication of guilt, which argues against its being a conviction under this definition; but no immigration authority has yet said so, and the officer applying the definition does not sit in this court. A park marijuana notice under the Park Service regulation is a federal controlled-substance charge. Montana's legal dispensaries sit a few miles from the West and North entrances, and possession inside the park is charged under the federal regulation regardless of where the product was bought.

Deportability, and moral turpitude

A separate provision makes a person deportable for a controlled-substance conviction after admission, with a single exception for one offense involving thirty grams or less of marijuana for personal use (§ 1227(a)(2)(B)(i)). On moral turpitude, the Board of Immigration Appeals has held that a simple DUI, without more, is not. The categories that draw scrutiny are theft, fraud, and offenses with an element of intent to harm, which is why a false statement to a ranger can matter more than the underlying ticket.

A DUI arrest and the visa in your passport

There is one statutory consequence, and it turns on the arrest rather than the outcome. The State Department's manual lets a consular officer, or the Department itself, prudentially revoke a nonimmigrant visa on the strength of a DUI arrest within the previous five years, on the theory that the arrest may signal a medical ground of ineligibility that only a panel physician can clear (9 FAM 403.11-5(B)). The rule reaches people already inside the United States, which the manual otherwise forbids, so the visa in an H-1B, L-1 or F-1 holder's passport can be cancelled while the park case is still open. Status inside the country is not lost, but the next trip abroad ends at a consulate with a new application and a physician's appointment before the return flight. Anyone on a visa who is arrested for DUI in either park should plan travel around that before booking anything.

Speeding, open container, wildlife, thermal areas

These are not controlled-substance offenses and not crimes of moral turpitude. The concern is the record itself and the disclosure questions that follow it, and the difference between a paid Box B notice, which is a disposed federal case, and a dismissal or an infraction-level resolution, which is a much shorter answer on a form. Thermal-area and wildlife cases often add a probation term with a park ban, and probation is something several immigration forms ask about directly.

Question-and-answer sites will tell you a park notice is "an infraction" that "does not require disclosure" and "will not show up." Read the form instead. The I-485 and the N-400 ask whether you have ever been cited, and how the case ended is the next question. A paid forfeiture is not a conviction under the federal court's 2026 rule, but that is an argument to make with the written disposition in hand, not a reason to skip the question. The people answering online have not seen your form; the officer at your interview will.

Two lawyers

I am not an immigration lawyer, and I will not pretend to be one on this page. What I do is the criminal side: get the file, read the regulation, deal with the Assistant U.S. Attorney, and shape the disposition. What I insist on, for a non-citizen client, is doing that in conversation with immigration counsel, yours or one I can recommend, so that the terms I ask the court for are the terms that survive the immigration definition of conviction. A dismissal is easy to evaluate. A deferred agreement, an amended charge, or a plea to a different regulation has to be drafted with the statute open, and the drafting is where these cases are won or lost. Immigration processes have their own calendars, and a pending petty-offense case in Wyoming can stall a renewal or an interview until it is resolved.

A Japanese passport on a weathered wooden table with the Teton Range behind
Resolve it before the flight home, and keep the written disposition with the passport

From the forums, answered.

I was visiting on ESTA and got a speeding ticket in Yellowstone. Do I have to declare it on my next ESTA?
No. The ESTA questions ask about arrests or convictions for crimes that caused serious damage to property or serious harm to a person, and about violations of drug laws. A speeding notice is neither, and a notice handed to you at the roadside is not an arrest. Resolve it before you leave, keep the written disposition, and answer the questions as they are worded. What does change the answer is a drug charge, or a notice you never dealt with that has become a warrant; a thirty-minute call before you pay anything is cheaper than either.
I am from Canada, Germany, Japan or Korea. Will a park ticket stop me at the border next time?
A traffic notice or a petty offense that ended with a payment to the court will not. An open case with a missed date, a warrant, or a controlled-substance conviction can, and a DUI arrest changes the paperwork at the consulate even when the case ends well. The table above goes charge by charge. Whatever the charge, resolve the notice before you travel, carry the written disposition, and answer the entry questions truthfully; the officer can see an open federal case, and a misrepresentation to enter the country is far worse than any ticket.
Can I leave the United States while the case is still open?
Yes. Nothing about a violation notice stops you from going home, and most of my park clients are home before the first court date. What matters is that the case is being handled while you are away: a lawyer who has entered an appearance can resolve most notices without you, and the federal court's rule allows the arraignment, plea and sentencing to proceed in your absence with your written consent and the judge's permission. The one thing not to do is leave with a Box A date on the calendar and no one answering for you.
I am on an H-1B and got a Yellowstone speeding ticket. Will it affect my status?
A speeding notice, on its own, is not the kind of offense the immigration statute is written around; it is not a controlled-substance offense and it is not the sort of conduct treated as morally turpitudinous. The practical problem is how a paid notice reads on future forms: under the federal court's 2026 rule a paid forfeiture is not a conviction and not an admission, but the forms ask about citations however they ended, the immigration definition of a conviction is applied by someone other than this court, and paying forecloses a dismissal. Talk to me and to your immigration counsel before paying, not after.
The ticket is for marijuana. It was legal where I bought it.
The immigration statute makes a person inadmissible for a conviction of, or an admission to, violating any law "relating to a controlled substance," with no exception for small amounts, and while under the federal court's 2026 rule a paid forfeiture is not an admission or an adjudication of guilt, the record it leaves is a controlled-substance regulation, the immigration definition is applied by an officer who does not sit in this court, and paying forecloses the dismissal or amended charge that leaves nothing of the kind. Do not pay it. Do not discuss the facts with anyone but a lawyer. The entire objective of the case becomes a disposition that is not a controlled-substance conviction, and that objective is reachable more often than people fear.
Does paying the ticket count as a "conviction" for immigration purposes?
It may. Immigration law defines conviction broadly to include a plea or an admission of facts sufficient for a finding of guilt where some penalty was imposed, and while the federal court's rule says a paid forfeiture is neither an admission nor an adjudication of guilt, no immigration authority has yet said how it reads a paid park notice, and the officer applying the definition does not sit in this court. Whether a particular paid notice meets the definition is a question for immigration counsel with the notice in hand; the safe course, before paying, is to assume it might.
Do I have to disclose a park citation on a visa application or at naturalization?
Read the question on the form. Visa applications ask whether you have ever been arrested or convicted of any offense, without a traffic-ticket exception in the question itself; naturalization asks about citations, arrests, and convictions, and requires good moral character during the statutory period. A truthful answer about a resolved petty offense is usually manageable. An untruthful answer is a separate and far worse problem. The point of handling the case carefully is to make the truthful answer a short one.
I am Canadian. Anything special?
Two things. First, the same federal case rules apply, and a Canadian citizen can be represented from home like anyone else. Second, Canada treats impaired driving abroad as serious criminality for people entering Canada who are not citizens, so an American with a Yellowstone DUI conviction can find the border a problem; a Canadian citizen returning home does not face that bar, but a permanent resident of Canada may. Either way, a DUI or refusal charge deserves counsel on both sides of the border.
Will the court tell my consulate?
Not on its own. The court is required to advise a non-citizen defendant of the right to have a consular officer notified, and the right to ask that the consulate be told; it is a right, not an automatic report. Nothing in the process forces the consulate into your case unless you want it there, and for most petty-offense cases there is no reason to invite it.

Find your citation.

Every page below is written for one kind of notice. Start with the one that matches yours.

Start

Start with a confidential conversation with Aaron Herzberg.

National-park matters begin with a thirty-minute call, and almost everything after that can be handled from wherever you are. Book it through the chat button in the corner of this page, or send the note here and my office will call you, usually the same business day. Have your violation notice in hand so we can read the box together, and call or text any time. Video consultations are available in Chinese, Korean, Japanese, Spanish, French, German and Italian, with live translation software, on request.

40 E Simpson Ave, Jackson, WY 83001 · by appointment · video consultations for out-of-state clients · info@puzzlegroup.com

Write to me

A sentence or two is plenty. Read by a person, not a call center, usually the same business day.

Sending this doesn't create an attorney-client relationship, and I can't treat it as confidential until we've cleared conflicts, so keep it general. By sending, you agree we may reply by phone, email, or text.

  1. Your note reaches me directly; my office runs the conflicts check, usually the same business day.
  2. We book the thirty-minute call; the chat button in the corner can do it at once, from any time zone.
  3. On the call we read the notice together, and you leave knowing what I would do first.